We asked NAHS students, "How long did you believe in Santa, and how did you find out he wasn't real?"
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Giovy Funari
Grade 9
![]() |
| Photo: Christmas City |
"I believed in Santa until I was 11 or 12. The whole thing was an accident. I went to find wrapping paper, and the last place I looked was the storage closet, and there were all of my gifts. I was suspicious through the years. How can Santa and my mom have the same handwriting?"
-----------------------------------------------------------------
![]() |
| Photo: Christmas City |
Zehra Naqvi
Grade 12
"I believed in Santa until I was 6 ,and I found out he wasn't real when I woke up in the middle of the night and saw my parents putting the presents under the tree."
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Liam Ashley
Grade 10
![]() |
| Photo: Christmas City |
"I believed in Santa until I was 11 years old. I figured out he was not real because how can someone eat so many cookies? Then, my dad told me he wasn’t real."
-----------------------------------------------------------------
![]() |
| Photo: Christmas City |
Brendan Alvino
Grade 10
"I believed in Santa until 6th grade. Then I figured out he wasn't real when my mother purchased her 'Santa' gifts in front of me."
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Alec Paradiso
Grade 9
| Photo: Maggie Lefebvre |
"Wait, what? Santa isn’t real? I thought he was real!! NO NO! This can’t be. My mommy and daddy told me he was real!! If Santa isn’t real then who eats the cookies? Santa! Santa is real."
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Got another great answer to this question? Comment below!



